Pizza. The very word conjures images of warm, cheesy goodness, a perfect crust, and endless topping possibilities. But the American pizza landscape is far from uniform. Three distinct regional styles reign supreme: New York, Chicago, and Detroit. Each boasts a unique character, from crust thickness to sauce application, and even the type of cheese used. This article will explore the history, ingredients, and preparation methods that set these three pizza titans apart.
The New York Slice: A Classic of Simplicity
The New York-style pizza is arguably the most recognizable. It’s characterized by its large, thin, hand-tossed crust, moderate cheese coverage, and signature foldable quality. A true New York slice is designed for eating on the go, a convenient and delicious street food staple.
Origins and Evolution
New York-style pizza traces its roots back to the first Italian immigrants who arrived in New York City in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Lombardi’s, opened in 1905, is generally considered the first pizzeria in the United States, and its pies set the standard for what would become the New York style. The key was using coal-fired ovens to achieve a crispy yet chewy crust. Over time, gas ovens became more common, leading to slight variations in texture, but the core elements remained.
Key Ingredients and Preparation
The dough for New York-style pizza is typically made with high-gluten bread flour, water, salt, sugar, and olive oil. It’s allowed to ferment for an extended period, often overnight, to develop flavor and structure. This fermentation process contributes to the crust’s characteristic chewiness. The dough is then hand-tossed, creating a large, thin base.
The sauce is simple, usually consisting of crushed tomatoes, oregano, basil, garlic, salt, and pepper. It’s spread thinly over the dough, leaving a small crust edge.
Mozzarella cheese, typically low-moisture, whole-milk mozzarella, is generously applied. The balance of cheese and sauce is crucial for achieving the right flavor profile.
New York-style pizzas are typically baked in deck ovens at high temperatures (around 500-600°F). This ensures a crispy bottom crust and a slightly charred top.
The Art of the Fold
The defining characteristic of a New York slice is its ability to be folded in half lengthwise for easy eating. This requires a thin, flexible crust that can support the weight of the toppings without breaking. The fold allows for a concentrated burst of flavor with each bite.
Chicago Deep-Dish: A Pizza of Epic Proportions
Chicago deep-dish pizza is a completely different beast. It’s characterized by its tall, buttery crust that resembles a pie more than a traditional pizza. Loaded with cheese, sauce, and toppings, it’s a hearty and indulgent meal.
Birth in the Windy City
The origin of Chicago deep-dish is often attributed to Ike Sewell, who opened Pizzeria Uno in 1943. Sewell wanted to create a pizza that was more substantial and filling than the thin-crust pies common at the time. The result was a pizza with a thick, deep crust and a generous amount of toppings.
The Deep-Dish Construction
The most striking feature of Chicago deep-dish is its crust. It’s made with a higher proportion of fat, often butter or oil, which gives it a flaky, biscuit-like texture. The dough is pressed into a deep, round pan, creating a tall wall that holds the copious fillings.
The cheese is applied directly to the crust, forming a protective layer that prevents the sauce from making the crust soggy. Mozzarella is the cheese of choice, and it’s used in abundant quantities.
The toppings are layered on top of the cheese, and then, in a unique twist, the sauce is added last. This unusual order of operations is essential for ensuring that the cheese melts properly and the crust remains crisp.
The sauce for Chicago deep-dish is typically a chunky tomato sauce, often with large pieces of tomatoes, herbs, and spices. It’s rich, flavorful, and designed to complement the other ingredients.
Chicago deep-dish pizzas are baked for a longer period of time than other styles, typically 30-45 minutes, to ensure that the crust is fully cooked and the cheese is melted and bubbly.
A Fork and Knife Affair
Unlike the New York slice, Chicago deep-dish is not designed to be eaten by hand. It’s too thick and heavy, requiring a fork and knife to navigate its layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings. It’s a meal in itself, and a single slice can be surprisingly filling.
Detroit-Style Pizza: The Square with a Crispy Edge
Detroit-style pizza is a relative newcomer to the national pizza scene, but it has quickly gained a devoted following. It’s characterized by its square shape, thick, airy crust, crispy, cheesy edges, and sauce dollops on top.
From Automotive Pans to Pizza Perfection
Detroit-style pizza originated in the 1940s at Buddy’s Rendezvous, a bar on Detroit’s east side. The original owner, Gus Guerra, used blue steel automotive parts pans to bake his pizzas, creating a unique shape and texture. The pans, originally used to hold small parts in automobile factories, proved to be ideal for creating a pizza with crispy edges and a light, airy interior.
The Detroit Dough and its Distinctive Crust
The dough for Detroit-style pizza is typically a high-hydration dough, meaning it contains a higher proportion of water to flour. This results in a light, airy crust with a slightly chewy texture. The dough is pressed into the rectangular steel pans, which have been heavily oiled to prevent sticking and promote crispy edges.
Wisconsin brick cheese is the traditional cheese used for Detroit-style pizza. It has a mild, buttery flavor and melts beautifully, creating a golden-brown crust that extends all the way to the edges of the pan. The cheese is spread generously, reaching the edges of the pan, where it caramelizes and crisps up during baking.
The sauce is typically a simple tomato sauce, often with a slightly sweet flavor. It’s applied in dollops on top of the cheese after baking, rather than being spread underneath. This prevents the sauce from making the crust soggy and allows the cheese to fully caramelize.
Detroit-style pizzas are baked in deck ovens at medium-high temperatures (around 450-500°F). The pans conduct heat evenly, ensuring that the crust is crispy on the bottom and edges while remaining soft and airy in the middle.
Those Coveted Corner Pieces
The hallmark of Detroit-style pizza is its crispy, cheesy edges. The cheese that spills over the edges of the crust caramelizes in the hot pan, creating a crunchy, flavorful border that is highly prized by pizza lovers. The corner pieces, with their extra-crispy edges, are particularly coveted.
Comparing the Three: A Side-by-Side Look
While each pizza style is undeniably delicious, they offer distinct experiences. The differences lie in the crust, cheese, sauce, and overall eating experience.
Crust Characteristics
The crust is perhaps the most defining feature.
-
New York: Thin, foldable, chewy, and slightly crispy.
-
Chicago: Deep, buttery, flaky, and biscuit-like.
-
Detroit: Thick, airy, crispy edges, and soft interior.
Cheese Choices and Application
The type and amount of cheese also vary significantly.
-
New York: Low-moisture mozzarella, moderate amount.
-
Chicago: Mozzarella, abundant amount, layered directly on the crust.
-
Detroit: Wisconsin brick cheese, generous amount, extending to the edges of the pan.
Sauce Strategies
The sauce placement and style contribute to the overall flavor profile.
-
New York: Thinly spread tomato sauce with herbs and spices.
-
Chicago: Chunky tomato sauce with large pieces of tomatoes, added on top of the cheese.
-
Detroit: Tomato sauce dollops applied after baking.
The Eating Experience
Ultimately, each style offers a unique way to enjoy pizza.
-
New York: Meant to be eaten on the go, folded in half.
-
Chicago: Requires a fork and knife, a hearty and filling meal.
-
Detroit: Can be eaten by hand, the crispy edges are a highlight.
Understanding the nuances of each style allows you to appreciate the artistry and regional pride that goes into creating these iconic American pizzas. Whether you prefer the simplicity of a New York slice, the indulgence of a Chicago deep-dish, or the crispy edges of a Detroit-style pie, there’s a pizza out there for everyone. Each style offers a unique and delicious experience, reflecting the culinary diversity of the United States. So, next time you’re craving pizza, consider trying something new and exploring the world of regional pizza styles. You might just discover your new favorite.